IVF PulseFree Second Opinion

Fertilisation failure; total fertilisation failure (TFF); low fertilisation rate

Eggs didn't fertilise: causes of low or failed fertilisation

The short answer

Fertilisation depends on the egg, the sperm and the lab, and one cycle rarely shows which. Complete failure after ICSI happens in about 1–5% of cycles, most often because the egg was not activated 1. For the next cycle, the choices are IVF versus ICSI and, after 0% or under 30% fertilisation, artificial oocyte activation 2.

Your eggs were collected, and the call from the lab on day 1 said none of them had fertilised, or only one or two out of many. Because this stage happens entirely in the lab, it is hard not to wonder whether the eggs, the sperm or the embryologist was the problem.

This page separates complete fertilisation failure from a low fertilisation rate, because they lead to different next steps. It explains how labs are expected to perform on this measure, what is known about IVF versus ICSI after a failed cycle, and how strong the evidence is for artificial oocyte activation, using the ESHRE–ALPHA Vienna consensus, ESHRE's 2023 add-ons recommendations and the UK regulator, the HFEA 1,2,3.

How common is this?

1–5%

ICSI cycles in which no egg, or virtually none, fertilises (ESHRE–ALPHA Vienna consensus)1,7

under 5%

Share of stimulated conventional IVF cycles with no fertilisation at all that a competent lab should stay below1

65%

Benchmark 80%

Minimum lab average for normally fertilised eggs after ICSI, counted per mature egg injected, in the lab's reference group1

60%

Benchmark 75%

Same measure for conventional IVF, counted per egg inseminated1

5% vs 6%

Couples with fertilisation failure after ICSI vs conventional IVF, in a trial of 1,064 couples whose sperm count and motility were normal4

Reading your report

MII (metaphase II) egg
A mature egg. Only mature eggs can be injected in ICSI, and a lab's ICSI fertilisation rate is counted against mature eggs injected, not all eggs collected 1.
2PN
Two pronuclei, seen about 17 hours after insemination or injection. It is the sign of normal fertilisation: one set of genetic material from the egg and one from the sperm 1.
1PN / 3PN
One or three pronuclei: abnormal fertilisation. These eggs are not counted as normally fertilised. The Vienna consensus expects 1PN below 5% of eggs after IVF and below 3% after ICSI, and more than two pronuclei after IVF below 6% 1.
Degenerated after ICSI
An egg damaged by injection, or found degenerated at the day-1 check. The Vienna consensus expects this in no more than 10% of injected eggs, ideally 5% or fewer 1.
Total fertilisation failure (TFF)
No egg shows two pronuclei on day 1, in a cycle where eggs were inseminated or injected.
Oocyte activation
The chain of calcium signals, normally triggered by a sperm enzyme called PLC zeta, that wakes the egg up after sperm entry. If it does not happen, the egg does not develop 2.
AOA (artificial oocyte activation)
A lab technique, usually a calcium ionophore added after ICSI, that triggers activation artificially 2.

Likely causes, most common first

CauseHow you'd knowTest that tells you
The eggs were immatureYour embryology report lists how many eggs were mature (MII). The Vienna consensus expects 75–90% of eggs collected to be mature at ICSI; a lower share points to stimulation or trigger timing rather than the lab 1. In one clinic's series, cycles with complete failure had fewer mature eggs than the same couples' other cycles 6.Review of the stimulation chart and trigger timing with your doctor
The egg was not activated after sperm entryMature eggs were injected by ICSI, yet none or very few fertilised. The Vienna consensus names activation failure as the principal cause of ICSI fertilisation failure 1; ESHRE says the deficiency can come from the sperm or the egg 2.Usually inferred from the result itself. ESHRE ties activation treatment to the fertilisation result (0% or under 30%), not to a routine test 2; specialised tests of sperm activation capacity, such as the mouse oocyte activation test, have been proposed to pre-screen couples before activation treatment 7.
A specific sperm defect, such as round-headed sperm (globozoospermia)Seen on sperm morphology. ESHRE lists globozoospermia as one of only three situations where artificial activation is recommended 2.Semen analysis performed to the WHO 2021 laboratory manual methods 8
Sperm could not enter the egg in conventional IVFConventional IVF was used and nothing fertilised. The Vienna consensus says this can reflect sperm function, egg activation, the receptors on the gametes, how the sperm was prepared, or the number of sperm used 1.Semen analysis; discussion of ICSI for the next cycle 1,2
Lab handling or conditionsYou cannot tell from one cycle. Signs worth asking about are a high number of eggs degenerated after injection, or a lab-wide fertilisation rate below the Vienna competency values 1.Ask the lab for its own ICSI and IVF fertilisation rates and its ICSI damage rate 1

What did not cause this

  • "Stress stopped the eggs fertilising"

    A BMJ meta-analysis of 14 prospective studies (3,583 women) found that anxiety or depression before treatment was not associated with whether a cycle led to pregnancy 9. Fertilisation happens in a dish in the lab.

  • "We should have insisted on ICSI from the start"

    In a randomised trial of couples with normal sperm count and motility, fertilisation failure occurred in 5% with ICSI and 6% with conventional IVF, and live birth was not different 4. A 2026 meta-analysis of six trials found no live-birth benefit of ICSI without severe male factor 5.

  • "If it failed once, our eggs and sperm can't make embryos"

    In one US clinic's series of 555 couples with complete fertilisation failure, 44% of IVF couples and 36% of ICSI couples who continued treatment went on to deliver a baby 6. The data are from a single clinic and are old, but they show one failed cycle is not a verdict.

Is it total fertilisation failure or a low fertilisation rate?

Total fertilisation failure means that at the day-1 check, about 17 hours after insemination or injection, no egg shows the two pronuclei of normal fertilisation 1. A low fertilisation rate means some eggs fertilised, but fewer than expected.

The distinction matters because the thresholds for action are specific. ESHRE's 2023 add-ons group recommends artificial oocyte activation after complete activation failure (0% fertilised) or very low fertilisation, which it defines as under 30% 2. A cycle with, say, 40% fertilised is below a lab's average but does not meet that definition.

Check how your rate was counted. For ICSI the lab divides normally fertilised eggs by mature eggs injected; for conventional IVF it divides by all eggs inseminated 1. A report that says '3 of 10' may mean 3 of 5 mature eggs, which reads very differently.

What fertilisation rate should an IVF lab achieve?

The ESHRE–ALPHA Vienna consensus sets two figures for each lab measure: a competency value, which is the minimum expected, and a benchmark, which is best practice 1. For normal fertilisation after ICSI they are 65% and 80% of mature eggs injected. For conventional IVF they are 60% and 75% of eggs inseminated. Conventional IVF cycles with no fertilisation at all should be under 5% 1.

These are averages across a lab's reference group, defined as women under 40 using their own fresh eggs, with ejaculated sperm and no genetic testing 1. They are not a pass mark for a single cycle. With five mature eggs, one egg more or less moves the rate by 20 percentage points.

What the Vienna consensus does say about individual cycles is that every case of complete fertilisation failure after ICSI should be reported and investigated by the lab 1. It is reasonable to ask what that investigation found, and to ask for the lab's own fertilisation and damage rates over the past year.

Why do eggs fail to fertilise?

Egg factors come first in practice. Only mature eggs can fertilise normally, and the Vienna consensus treats a mature-egg share outside 75–90% as a signal to review stimulation and trigger timing 1. In a series of 555 couples, the cycle that failed had fewer mature eggs than the couples' cycles before or after it 6.

Sperm factors include a lack of the sperm protein PLC zeta that normally triggers egg activation, and structural defects such as globozoospermia 2,7. ESHRE's implantation-failure group notes that abnormal sperm concentration, motility and morphology are associated with low fertilisation and poor embryo development 10.

Lab factors include how sperm is prepared, how many sperm are used in conventional IVF, and ICSI technique, which shows up as eggs damaged or degenerated after injection 1. A single failed cycle usually cannot separate these, which is why the egg count, the maturity count and the semen result need to be read together.

Should the next cycle use IVF or ICSI?

If conventional IVF was used and nothing fertilised, ICSI bypasses the steps where sperm must bind to and enter the egg. ESHRE notes that ICSI improved fertilisation and pregnancy rates in couples with severe male factor infertility 2. We did not find a randomised trial of ICSI specifically after a failed conventional IVF cycle with normal semen, so for that situation the benefit is assumed rather than tested.

If there is no male factor and no previous failure, ESHRE does not recommend ICSI 2. In a Vietnamese trial of 1,064 couples with normal sperm count and motility, live birth after the first transfer was 35% with ICSI and 31% with IVF, a difference that was not statistically significant 4. A 2026 meta-analysis found no benefit of ICSI in live birth (32.8% vs 34.5%) or cumulative live birth (43.2% vs 47.4%) for couples without severe male factor 5.

If ICSI was already used and failed, switching method is not an option. The question then becomes egg maturity and egg activation.

What is artificial oocyte activation, and how strong is the evidence?

Artificial oocyte activation (AOA) usually means placing eggs in a calcium ionophore solution for 10–30 minutes after ICSI, to raise calcium inside the egg 2. ESHRE's 2023 add-ons recommendations do not recommend it routinely, but do recommend it after complete activation failure (0% fertilised), very low fertilisation (under 30%) or globozoospermia 2.

The evidence is real but weak. A meta-analysis cited by ESHRE pooled 14 studies (3,621 patients, only 4 of them randomised trials) and found higher live birth with AOA, with high variability between studies and signs of publication bias 2. In patients with previous fertilisation failure or low fertilisation the effect was larger, based on 7 studies and 1,294 patients 2. ESHRE rates the quality of the evidence for both benefit and safety as low, meaning mainly observational data 2.

On safety, the same meta-analysis found no significant difference in birth defects between AOA and standard ICSI across 13 studies with 4,320 participants 2. ESHRE still asks for long-term monitoring of children, because the calcium signal is a single artificial peak rather than the natural pattern, and small studies have reported changes in gene methylation 2.

The UK regulator is more cautious about when to start. The HFEA removed calcium-ionophore activation from its rated add-on list in October 2023 because it should be offered only to selected patients, and quotes UK professional guidance that AOA may be used after two previous routine ICSI cycles with under 30% or no fertilisation 3. ESHRE's wording allows it after one such cycle 2. Ask your clinic which rule it follows and why.

Does one failed fertilisation predict the next cycle?

Not reliably. In a US clinic series of 555 couples with complete fertilisation failure, those who continued treatment had delivery rates of 22% per cycle after failed conventional IVF and 18% per cycle after failed ICSI 6. The authors linked the failures mainly to a poorer response to stimulation in that cycle 6.

This is one clinic's data from before 2008, so the numbers should not be read as your odds. The useful point is that a repeat of the same result is not a foregone conclusion, particularly when the failed cycle produced few mature eggs.

It depends on…

How did the last cycle fail?

Conventional IVF, no eggs fertilised

ICSI is the usual next step; ask whether the semen result or sperm preparation explains it 1,2.

ICSI, no eggs fertilised, and most eggs were mature

This fits ESHRE's first indication for artificial oocyte activation (0% fertilised) 2.

ICSI, under 30% fertilised

ESHRE lists this as an indication for activation 2; UK guidance quoted by the HFEA waits for a second such cycle 3.

Few eggs were mature

The first question is stimulation and trigger timing, not the lab or the sperm 1,6.

30% or more fertilised

Below a lab average, but not an ESHRE indication for activation 2; look at what the embryos did next.

What's worth checking

  • Get the embryology report: eggs collected, eggs mature (MII), eggs injected or inseminated, and eggs with 2PN on day 1.
  • Note how many eggs showed 1PN or 3PN, and how many degenerated after injection.
  • Check whether the cycle used conventional IVF or ICSI, and whether the sperm was fresh, frozen or surgically retrieved.
  • Ask for the semen result from the day of egg collection, not only an older report.
  • Ask the lab for its own IVF and ICSI fertilisation rates and ICSI damage rate over the past year.
  • If fertilisation was 0% or under 30% after ICSI, ask whether artificial oocyte activation is being considered, and what safety information the clinic gives about it 2.
  • List every previous cycle's fertilisation result, so a pattern can be separated from a one-off.

What could change next cycle

6 options, by strength of evidence

  • Good evidence it helps 1
  • Mixed, or some groups only 1
  • Not enough studies yet 3
  • Evidence says it doesn't help 1

Ratings follow the evidence reviews cited beside each option, not our opinion.

  • ICSI when semen parameters are clearly abnormalGood evidence it helps

    ESHRE: ICSI improved fertilisation and pregnancy rates in severe male factor infertility 2.

  • ICSI after a failed conventional IVF cycle, with normal semenNot enough studies yet

    No trial of this exact situation retrieved; in first cycles with normal sperm, ICSI did not reduce fertilisation failure (5% vs 6%) 4.

  • ICSI routinely, without male factor or previous failureEvidence says it doesn't help

    ESHRE: not recommended 2; 2026 meta-analysis of six trials found no live-birth benefit 5.

  • Artificial oocyte activation after 0% or under 30% fertilisation with ICSI, or globozoospermiaMixed, or some groups only

    ESHRE: recommended for these cases only, on low-quality evidence 2; HFEA: selected patients only, with UK guidance waiting for two such cycles 3.

  • Artificial oocyte activation for everyone having ICSINot enough studies yet

    ESHRE: not recommended for routine use 2; HFEA: safety for the child not yet established 3.

  • Reviewing stimulation and trigger timing if many eggs were immatureNot enough studies yet

    The Vienna consensus says a mature-egg share outside 75–90% should prompt this review 1; no outcome trial of the review itself.

Questions to ask your doctor

  1. How many of my eggs were mature, and how many of those fertilised normally?
  2. Was the lab's investigation of this cycle able to point to the eggs, the sperm or the procedure?
  3. What are this lab's ICSI and IVF fertilisation rates and ICSI damage rate for patients like me?
  4. Would you change the insemination method next time, and on what evidence?
  5. Does my result meet ESHRE's criteria for artificial oocyte activation, and what do you tell patients about its safety?
  6. Would you change my stimulation or trigger timing to get more mature eggs?

Questions people ask

Can frozen sperm cause fertilisation failure?

The Vienna consensus includes both fresh and frozen ejaculated sperm in its reference group for ICSI fertilisation, so frozen ejaculated sperm is not treated as a separate risk 1. It notes that results may be lower with surgically retrieved sperm 1.

Did the lab make a mistake if no eggs fertilised?

Not necessarily; egg activation problems from the sperm or the egg are the main cause after ICSI 1,2. The Vienna consensus asks labs to investigate every complete ICSI failure, so you are entitled to ask what that review found 1.

Is 50% fertilisation after ICSI bad?

It is below the Vienna consensus minimum lab average of 65%, but that figure describes a lab's results across many patients, not one cycle 1. It is well above the under-30% level at which ESHRE recommends considering artificial activation 2.

Is a sperm DNA fragmentation test useful after fertilisation failure?

ESHRE's 2023 add-ons group does not recommend sperm DNA fragmentation testing for routine use, saying there is insufficient evidence it predicts pregnancy or should guide treatment 2. The male-factor page covers the test and the guideline disagreement in detail.

Can they do ICSI the next day if the eggs did not fertilise?

That is late rescue ICSI, done about 18-24 hours after conventional insemination on eggs showing no sign of fertilisation. A 2021 systematic review of 22 studies found fresh transfers after it did poorly, with 10% clinical pregnancy per transfer, while transfers of frozen embryos from rescue ICSI reached 36% 11. It is only an option after conventional IVF, not after ICSI 11.

My report says 0PN or 1PN. Can that embryo be used?

They are not counted as normal fertilisation, and the ESHRE-Alpha consensus expects 1PN in under 5% of inseminated eggs after IVF and under 3% after ICSI 1. Some still develop: in a Chinese series of single frozen blastocyst transfers, 290 from 0PN and 92 from 1PN zygotes gave pregnancy and live birth rates similar to 1,906 from 2PN zygotes 12. Clinics differ on whether to grow and transfer them.

What does 3PN on my report mean?

Three or more pronuclei is abnormal fertilisation, caused either by the egg failing to expel its second polar body or by more than one sperm entering it 1. After conventional IVF the consensus expects this in under 6% of inseminated eggs and notes a published incidence of 4-7% 1. Immature or over-mature eggs and a very high sperm concentration in the dish can raise it 1.

Does the embryology report show whether it was an egg problem or a sperm problem?

Rarely on its own. It gives you counts: eggs collected, eggs mature, eggs injected or inseminated, eggs degenerated, and eggs with two pronuclei on day 1 1. Those counts can point towards stimulation when few eggs were mature, or towards technique when many degenerated 1. When mature eggs were injected and none fertilised, the report cannot say whether the sperm or the egg failed to start the process 2.

Is there a test that shows whether the sperm can activate an egg?

Not one in routine clinical use. Research groups have used the heterologous mouse oocyte activation test and calcium measurements in eggs to screen couples before offering artificial activation, but a 2022 review describes both those diagnostics and activation treatment itself as experimental 7. ESHRE ties its recommendation to the fertilisation result, 0% or under 30%, rather than to any test 2.

The semen report was normal, so how could fertilisation fail?

A semen analysis counts the sperm and measures how they move and how they are shaped, by the WHO 2021 laboratory methods 8. It does not measure whether a sperm can switch the egg on, which is the step that fails in most ICSI fertilisation failures 1,7. ESHRE's implantation failure group links abnormal sperm results to low fertilisation, but a normal result does not rule a sperm factor out 10.

Is ICSI riskier for the baby than conventional IVF?

The published comparisons do not show a difference. ESHRE's 2023 add-ons group reports that perinatal outcomes appear comparable between IVF and ICSI, in a large retrospective study, a meta-analysis of 46 studies and a randomised trial of more than 1,000 couples, and rates the safety of ICSI as similar to IVF on low-quality evidence 2. Most of that data comes from couples with male factor infertility, which makes the infertility itself hard to separate from the technique 2.

Does ICSI cost more than conventional IVF?

Yes, and ESHRE counts that against it when there is no male factor. ICSI takes significantly longer in the laboratory, and a cost analysis quoted by ESHRE put it 8.3% higher than conventional IVF 2. That analysis was Dutch, so the gap in rupees will differ; ask your clinic to itemise it. ESHRE does not recommend ICSI for non-male factor infertility 2.

Sources

  1. ESHRE Special Interest Group of Embryology and Alpha Scientists in Reproductive Medicine. The Vienna consensus: report of an expert meeting on the development of ART laboratory performance indicators. Hum Reprod Open. 2017;2017(2):hox011. ESHRE / ALPHA / Human Reproduction Open
  2. ESHRE Add-ons working group; Lundin K, Bentzen JG, Bozdag G, Ebner T, Harper J, et al. Good practice recommendations on add-ons in reproductive medicine. Hum Reprod. 2023;38(11):2062–2104. ESHRE / Human Reproduction
  3. Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority. Treatment add-ons with limited evidence: artificial egg activation (calcium ionophore), additional information. HFEA (UK regulator)
  4. Dang VQ, Vuong LN, Luu TM, et al. Intracytoplasmic sperm injection versus conventional in-vitro fertilisation in couples with infertility in whom the male partner has normal total sperm count and motility: an open-label, randomised controlled trial. Lancet. 2021;397(10284):1554–1563. The Lancet
  5. Kayimu K, Berntsen S, Fu Y, et al. Does intracytoplasmic sperm injection outperform conventional in vitro fertilization in couples without severe male factor infertility? A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Hum Reprod. 2026;41(7):1173–1182. Human Reproduction
  6. Kinzer DR, Barrett CB, Powers RD. Prognosis for clinical pregnancy and delivery after total fertilization failure during conventional in vitro fertilization or intracytoplasmic sperm injection. Fertil Steril. 2008;90(2):284–288. Fertility and Sterility
  7. Kashir J, Ganesh D, Jones C, Coward K. Oocyte activation deficiency and assisted oocyte activation: mechanisms, obstacles and prospects for clinical application. Hum Reprod Open. 2022;2022(2):hoac003. Human Reproduction Open
  8. World Health Organization. WHO laboratory manual for the examination and processing of human semen, 6th edition. Geneva: WHO; 2021. WHO
  9. Boivin J, Griffiths E, Venetis CA. Emotional distress in infertile women and failure of assisted reproductive technologies: meta-analysis of prospective psychosocial studies. BMJ. 2011;342:d223. BMJ
  10. ESHRE Working Group on Recurrent Implantation Failure; Cimadomo D, de los Santos MJ, Griesinger G, et al. ESHRE good practice recommendations on recurrent implantation failure. Hum Reprod Open. 2023;2023(3):hoad023. ESHRE / Human Reproduction Open
  11. Paffoni A, Reschini M, Pisaturo V, Guarneri C, Palini S, Vigano P. Should rescue ICSI be re-evaluated considering the deferred transfer of cryopreserved embryos in in-vitro fertilization cycles? A systematic review and meta-analysis. Reprod Biol Endocrinol. 2021;19(1):121. Reproductive Biology and Endocrinology
  12. Tong X, Jin J, Xue Y, Fang L, Zhu H, Jiang L, Zhang S. Clinical outcomes of frozen-thawed blastocysts from zygotes with no or one pronucleus for in vitro fertilization and intracytoplasmic sperm injection cycles. Arch Gynecol Obstet. 2023;308(3):1015-1022. Archives of Gynecology and Obstetrics

Tools for this step

WhatsApp us