The short answer
An embryo grade describes how the embryo looked under a microscope at one moment. It is not a test of whether it is healthy. Lower-grade blastocysts implant less often but still lead to births 2,5, and top-grade blastocysts can still carry chromosome errors 3. Grading also varies between laboratories 7.
Your embryology report came back with codes like 3BC, 4AB or 'grade 2, 8-cell', and someone may have called your embryos 'poor quality'. That phrase sounds final. It is a description of shape and cell appearance on a particular day, scored by one embryologist against a scale.
This page decodes those codes line by line, using the Gardner blastocyst scale and the day-3 criteria from the 2011 Istanbul consensus of ESHRE and ALPHA embryologists 1,2. It then sets out what published cohorts found a grade can and cannot tell you: about implantation, about live birth, and about whether an embryo has the right number of chromosomes.
How common is this?
25.0%
Live birth per transfer of a single poor-grade embryo already tested as chromosomally normal, versus 50.0% for excellent-grade, in 914 transfers at one Beijing centre2
10.8%
Live birth per transfer of a chromosomally normal poor-quality blastocyst (below BB) at one Italian centre, versus 44.6% for BB or better; women's mean age 39.65
56.4%
Share of 'excellent' blastocysts that tested chromosomally normal, versus 25.5% of 'poor' ones, in 956 biopsied blastocysts from women mostly over 35 or with past failures3
23.5%
Share of poor-quality blastocysts that tested chromosomally normal, versus 51% of better-graded ones, in the same Italian cohort5
Reading your report
- Gardner score (e.g. 4AA, 3BC, 5AB)
- A three-part code for a day 5–7 blastocyst: a number for how expanded it is, then a letter for the inner cell mass, then a letter for the trophectoderm 2. 4AB means expanded, inner cell mass A, trophectoderm B.
- Expansion 1–6
- 1 early blastocyst (fluid cavity less than half the embryo); 2 blastocyst (more than half); 3 full blastocyst (cavity fills the embryo); 4 expanded (larger, shell thinning); 5 hatching (starting to push out of its shell); 6 hatched (fully out) 2.
- Inner cell mass (ICM) A / B / C
- The cluster of cells that becomes the fetus. A: many tightly packed cells; B: several loosely grouped cells; C: very few cells 2.
- Trophectoderm (TE) A / B / C
- The outer layer of cells that becomes the placenta. A: many cells forming a cohesive layer; B: few cells forming a loose layer; C: very few, large cells 2.
- Grade 1 / 2 / 3 instead of A / B / C
- Some labs use the Istanbul consensus numbers, where 1 means good, 2 fair and 3 poor. Grade 1 is equivalent to Gardner A 1.
- Day 3, 8-cell
- The number of cells counted on day 3. The Istanbul consensus describes an optimal day-3 embryo as 8 equally sized cells, each with one nucleus, with under 10% fragmentation 1.
- Fragmentation
- Small pieces of cell material that have broken off inside the embryo, scored as a percentage of its volume. Istanbul grading: under 10% good, 10–25% fair, over 25% poor 1.
- Multinucleation (MNB)
- A cell containing more than one nucleus. The Istanbul consensus notes that transferring such embryos has been linked to lower implantation, pregnancy and birth rates 1.
- Day 5 / day 6 / day 7 blastocyst
- The day the embryo reached the blastocyst stage. In one cohort, poor-quality blastocysts were more often day 6 or 7 than better-graded ones 5.
- Euploid / aneuploid
- Euploid means a biopsy showed the expected number of chromosomes; aneuploid means extra or missing chromosomes. A grade cannot tell you this; only PGT-A tests it.
Likely causes, most common first
| Cause | How you'd know | Test that tells you |
|---|---|---|
| Chromosome errors in the embryo, which become more common as the egg ages | Poor morphology was linked to higher aneuploidy in two cohorts 3,5; in one, maternal age was the only factor that correlated with how many poor-quality blastocysts a woman had 5 | Only PGT-A shows chromosome number; it selects among embryos and does not improve them 8 |
| Slower development, so the embryo is graded later or looks less expanded | Day 6 or day 7 blastocyst on the report. In one cohort 29.4% of poor-quality blastocysts formed on day 7, versus 5.2% of better ones 5 | Day-by-day embryology notes |
| How the grade was assigned, not the embryo | ESHRE notes that embryo grading has limited reproducibility, especially between centres 7 | Ask which scale your lab uses and whether images or time-lapse videos were saved |
| Laboratory conditions | ESHRE lists the performance of the laboratory and clinic among the factors that affect the chance of implantation 7 | Ask for the lab's own blastocyst and implantation rates for patients of your age |
What did not cause this
"A poor grade means the embryo was never viable"
In an Italian cohort of 1,497 poor-quality blastocysts, the authors concluded that poor morphology does not by itself define a non-viable embryo, though the chance of live birth is lower 5.
"I must have done something to damage my eggs"
In the same cohort, maternal age at egg collection was the only factor that correlated with the number of poor-quality blastocysts a woman had 5. Age is not something you did.
"My embryos were all top grade, so the failure must be my uterus"
In one multicentre cohort, 43.6% of blastocysts graded excellent were not chromosomally normal 3. ESHRE describes aneuploid blastocysts as having negligible implantation potential 7.
How do I read a blastocyst grade like 4AA or 3BC?
Read it left to right. The number is expansion, from 1 (early blastocyst) to 6 (fully hatched out of its shell). The first letter is the inner cell mass, the cells that become the baby. The second letter is the trophectoderm, the outer layer that becomes the placenta. Each letter runs from A (many well-organised cells) to C (very few cells) 2.
Some labs give the two letters only once the blastocyst is a full blastocyst, stage 3 or beyond 2. Others also grade earlier blastocysts, which is why codes such as 2AB appear in some grading bands 2. A code of 3BC means a full blastocyst with a loosely grouped inner cell mass and very few trophectoderm cells.
Labs group these codes into bands differently. In the euploid studies below, 'excellent' meant 3AA or better, 'good' included 3–6AB and 3–6BA, 'average' included 3–6BB, 3–6AC and 3–6CA, and 'poor' included any BC, CB or CC 2,4. Another study called anything below BB 'poor quality' 5. Ask your lab which bands it uses before comparing your report with anyone else's.
How are day-3 embryos graded?
Day-3 (cleavage-stage) embryos are scored on cell number, whether the cells are even in size, fragmentation and multinucleation. The Istanbul consensus sets the expected cell count at 4 cells on day 2 and 8 cells on day 3, and grades fragmentation as under 10% (good), 10–25% (fair) or over 25% (poor) 1.
The same consensus states that under 10% fragmentation on day 3 has been found to have a negligible effect on implantation, while embryos with multinucleated cells have been linked to lower implantation, pregnancy and birth rates 1. It also notes that morphology screens out arrested and badly misshapen embryos but does not allow selection against aneuploidy 1.
Can a poor-quality embryo still become a baby?
Yes, though less often than a top-grade one. In 914 single transfers of chromosomally normal blastocysts at a Beijing centre, live birth per transfer was 50.0% for excellent, 49.7% for good, 42.3% for average and 25.0% for poor-grade embryos 2. In a US cohort of 417 frozen transfers of euploid embryos, ongoing pregnancy was 84.2% for excellent and 35.8% for poor-grade embryos 4.
In an Italian cohort with women's mean age 39.6, chromosomally normal blastocysts graded below BB had a 10.8% live-birth rate per transfer, against 44.6% for BB or better 5. Using these embryos added live births for 18 women who had no other route to one; most were over 42 or had few or no better embryos 5.
These figures come from single centres, mostly with tested embryos, and none are Indian. They show that a poor grade lowers the odds. They do not show that a poor-grade embryo is worthless, which is why some labs freeze or transfer embryos that others would discard. Ask your clinic what its policy is.
Does a top grade mean the embryo is chromosomally normal?
No. In a two-centre study of 956 biopsied blastocysts from women mostly over 35, or with past failed cycles or miscarriages, 56.4% of excellent, 39.1% of good, 42.8% of average and 25.5% of poor blastocysts were chromosomally normal 3. Better-looking embryos were more often normal, but a large share of top-grade ones were not.
The same study found that once an embryo was known to be euploid, its grade and whether it formed on day 5 or day 6 did not predict whether it implanted 3. Other cohorts disagree: the US and Beijing studies both found that grade still mattered among euploid embryos 2,4. The honest summary is that grade tracks chromosome status only loosely, and how much it matters after testing is still disputed.
Which part of the grade matters most?
The studies do not agree. In 1,117 fresh single blastocyst transfers, trophectoderm grade was the only independent predictor of live birth once other factors were adjusted for 6. In euploid frozen transfers at a US centre, inner cell mass grade A gave a 76.2% ongoing pregnancy rate, against 53.6% for grade B and 13.5% for grade C 4.
The Beijing euploid study found that a C in either the inner cell mass or the trophectoderm lowered pregnancy and live birth, and that the expansion number made no clear difference 2. If your report has a C in either letter, that is the part most studies treat as meaningful. A difference between 3 and 4, or 4 and 5, carries less weight on its own.
Can I compare my embryo grades with another clinic's?
Only loosely. The Istanbul consensus was written because the many grading schemes used by different clinics made inter-clinic comparisons extremely difficult 1. ESHRE's 2023 recommendations still describe embryo grading as having limited reproducibility, especially between centres 7.
If you move clinics, take the images or time-lapse videos if your lab saved them, not only the codes. A second lab can then look at the same embryos rather than someone else's shorthand.
Will time-lapse imaging or AI grading choose a better embryo?
Not on current evidence, if the question is your chance of a baby. The UK regulator, the HFEA, rates time-lapse incubation black for improving the chance of a baby, meaning moderate or high-quality evidence shows no effect, whether embryos are assessed manually or by algorithm 9. ESHRE's 2023 add-ons recommendations do not recommend time-lapse imaging as a way to improve live birth 8.
ESHRE describes AI-powered grading tools as still under investigation, with the aim of making embryo assessment more consistent in future 7.
Embryo grade decoder
| Part of the grade | What it describes | What the values mean |
|---|---|---|
| Blastocyst number (1–6) | How far the fluid cavity has expanded, and whether the embryo has hatched 2 | 1 early · 2 blastocyst · 3 full · 4 expanded · 5 hatching · 6 hatched 2 |
| First letter (A–C) | Inner cell mass, the cells that become the fetus 2 | A many, tightly packed · B several, loosely grouped · C very few 2 |
| Second letter (A–C) | Trophectoderm, the outer layer that becomes the placenta 2 | A many cells, cohesive layer · B few cells, loose layer · C very few large cells 2 |
| Grade 1–3 (Istanbul) | The same inner cell mass and trophectoderm scale written as numbers 1 | 1 good (equivalent to A) · 2 fair · 3 poor 1 |
| Day-3 cell count | Cells counted on day 3 1 | 8 equally sized cells is the consensus optimum 1 |
| Fragmentation | Share of the embryo taken up by fragments 1 | Under 10% good · 10–25% fair · over 25% poor 1 |
| Multinucleation | Any cell with more than one nucleus 1 | Linked to lower implantation and birth rates 1 |
| Day 5, 6 or 7 | The day the embryo became a blastocyst | Poor-quality blastocysts were more often day 6 or 7 in one cohort 5 |
What's worth checking
- Ask for the full embryology report, with each embryo's grade on each day, not only the summary.
- Ask which grading scale the lab uses and how it bands codes into good, average and poor.
- Note the day each blastocyst formed: day 5, 6 or 7 5.
- Check whether any grade has a C in the inner cell mass or trophectoderm 2.
- Ask what happens to lower-grade embryos in your lab: frozen, transferred or discarded.
- Ask whether images or time-lapse videos were saved, in case you seek a second opinion.
- Ask for the lab's own blastocyst rate for women of your age.
- Before paying for time-lapse or AI grading, ask for its HFEA rating 9.
What could change next cycle
3 options, by strength of evidence
- Mixed, or some groups only 2
- Evidence says it doesn't help 1
Ratings follow the evidence reviews cited beside each option, not our opinion.
- PGT-A to sort embryos by chromosome numberMixed, or some groups only
ESHRE: not recommended for routine use 8. HFEA: red for the chance of a baby, green for reducing miscarriage, for most patients 10.
- Time-lapse imaging or AI embryo selectionEvidence says it doesn't help
HFEA rates it black: no effect on the chance of a baby 9; ESHRE does not recommend it to improve live birth 8.
- Growing embryos to blastocyst before transferMixed, or some groups only
ESHRE: can be considered after repeated implantation failure; low-quality evidence of higher live birth with fresh blastocyst transfer 7.
Questions to ask your doctor
- Which grading scale does your lab use, and what did each of my embryos score on each day?
- Were any embryos discarded because of their grade, and what is your policy on lower-grade blastocysts?
- Did my embryos form on day 5, 6 or 7, and does that change your advice?
- Do you think the grades reflect my eggs, the sperm, or the lab conditions in this cycle, and why?
- What is your lab's blastocyst rate for women my age, and how did my cycle compare?
- Would you change anything in stimulation or the lab next time, and what evidence is that based on?
Questions people ask
Is a 3BB embryo good?
It is a full blastocyst with a B for both cell layers, which most labs place in the middle band. In the grouping used by the US and Beijing euploid studies, 3–6BB counts as 'average' 2,4. Among chromosomally normal embryos in the Beijing study, average-grade blastocysts had a 42.3% live-birth rate per transfer 2.
Is a day 6 blastocyst worse than a day 5?
It depends on the study. In one two-centre cohort, day-5 and day-6 blastocysts had similar aneuploidy rates, and among euploid embryos the day did not predict implantation 3. In an Italian cohort, poor-quality blastocysts were more often slow to form 5. Ask your clinic how its own day-6 embryos perform.
Does fragmentation mean the embryo is abnormal?
Why did one clinic call my embryos poor and another call them average?
How common is it for embryos to be poor quality?
Common enough to be routine. At one Italian centre doing chromosome testing, 1,497 of 6,747 blastocysts, about 22%, were graded poor quality, meaning below BB, across 2,757 egg collections in women averaging 39.6 years 5. How many a woman had correlated with her age at egg collection and with nothing else the authors measured 5.
Does a poor-quality embryo have a higher chance of miscarriage?
In one Italian cohort it did. Among transferred chromosomally normal blastocysts, miscarriage per clinical pregnancy was 36.4% after a poor-quality embryo, against 13.9% after a better-graded one 5. The authors caution that these embryos are transferred last, so the women receiving them were a poorer-prognosis group to begin with 5.
Are babies born from lower-grade embryos less healthy?
The data are limited and largely reassuring. Among 7,469 singleton births after frozen single blastocyst transfer at one Beijing hospital, a lower overall grade was associated with a slightly higher caesarean rate, 71% against 68% 11. A grade C inner cell mass was linked to larger babies and a grade C outer layer to smaller ones 11. The study was retrospective and grading is subjective 11.
Is a day 7 blastocyst worth transferring?
It carries a real but clearly lower chance. A 2026 systematic review of 17 studies covering 2,908 day-7 transfers found lower live birth than day-5 blastocysts (odds ratio 0.23) and day-6 blastocysts (0.37), with the gap still present when only chromosomally tested embryos were compared, and more miscarriages than day 5 12. The authors note day-7 embryos can still add live births, particularly for poor-prognosis patients 12.
Is a slow-growing embryo the same as a poor-quality one?
They overlap but are not the same thing. Grading describes how an embryo looks at a fixed observation time, which is why the Istanbul consensus sets those times 1. In the Italian cohort, only 10.1% of poor-quality blastocysts had formed by day 5, against 43.9% of better-graded ones, so slow embryos are often, but not always, the ones that end up graded poorly 5.
Does the grade still mean anything after the embryo is frozen and thawed?
Both the original grade and what the embryo does after warming appear to count. In 1,356 vitrified-warmed blastocyst transfers at one Japanese centre, how far the blastocyst re-expanded 9 to 11 minutes after warming predicted clinical pregnancy independently of the inner cell mass and outer layer grades 13. It is a single retrospective centre, so ask whether your laboratory records re-expansion at all 13.
Can supplements or a diet change improve embryo quality before the next cycle?
None has been shown to. ESHRE's add-ons group states that antioxidant therapy lacks reliable evidence of improving live birth and is not recommended in ART, and that adjuncts including DHEA, growth hormone, testosterone and metformin before or during stimulation are not recommended 8. In the Italian cohort, the woman's age at egg collection was the only factor that correlated with how many poor-quality blastocysts she had 5.
Can a poor-quality blastocyst be tested with PGT-A?
Yes, if it expands enough for a biopsy. In the Italian cohort, poor-quality blastocysts that were biopsied were chromosomally normal 23.5% of the time, against 51% of better-graded ones 5. Whether to test at all is a separate question: ESHRE does not recommend PGT-A for routine use 8, and the HFEA rates it red for the chance of a baby for most patients 10.
Sources
- Alpha Scientists in Reproductive Medicine and ESHRE Special Interest Group of Embryology. The Istanbul consensus workshop on embryo assessment: proceedings of an expert meeting. Hum Reprod. 2011;26(6):1270–1283. ESHRE / ALPHA / Human Reproduction
- Zhao YY, Yu Y, Zhang XW, et al. Overall blastocyst quality, trophectoderm grade, and inner cell mass grade predict pregnancy outcome in euploid blastocyst transfer cycles. Chin Med J (Engl). 2018;131(11):1261–1267. Chinese Medical Journal
- Capalbo A, Rienzi L, Cimadomo D, et al. Correlation between standard blastocyst morphology, euploidy and implantation: an observational study in two centers involving 956 screened blastocysts. Hum Reprod. 2014;29(6):1173–1181. Human Reproduction
- Irani M, Reichman D, Robles A, et al. Morphologic grading of euploid blastocysts influences implantation and ongoing pregnancy rates. Fertil Steril. 2017;107(3):664–670. Fertility and Sterility
- Cimadomo D, Soscia D, Vaiarelli A, et al. Looking past the appearance: a comprehensive description of the clinical contribution of poor-quality blastocysts to increase live birth rates during cycles with aneuploidy testing. Hum Reprod. 2019;34(7):1206–1214. Human Reproduction
- Ahlström A, Westin C, Reismer E, Wikland M, Hardarson T. Trophectoderm morphology: an important parameter for predicting live birth after single blastocyst transfer. Hum Reprod. 2011;26(12):3289–3296. Human Reproduction
- ESHRE Working Group on Recurrent Implantation Failure; Cimadomo D, de los Santos MJ, Griesinger G, et al. ESHRE good practice recommendations on recurrent implantation failure. Hum Reprod Open. 2023;2023(3):hoad023. ESHRE / Human Reproduction Open
- ESHRE Add-ons working group; Lundin K, Bentzen JG, Bozdag G, et al. Good practice recommendations on add-ons in reproductive medicine. Hum Reprod. 2023;38(11):2062–2104. ESHRE / Human Reproduction
- Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority. Time-lapse imaging and incubation (treatment add-on ratings). HFEA (UK regulator)
- Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority. Pre-implantation genetic testing for aneuploidy (PGT-A) (treatment add-on ratings). HFEA (UK regulator)
- Hu KL, Zheng X, Hunt S, Li X, Li R, Mol BW. Blastocyst quality and perinatal outcomes in women undergoing single blastocyst transfer in frozen cycles. Hum Reprod Open. 2021;2021(4):hoab036. ESHRE / Human Reproduction Open
- Firmin J, Ducreux B, Saidessalam H, et al. Clinical outcomes of Day-7 blastocysts: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Hum Reprod Update. 2026;dmag017 (online ahead of print). ESHRE / Human Reproduction Update
- Yoneyama M, Ito A, Katagiri Y, Oigawa S, Nagao K, Nakata M. The degree of blastocyst re-expansion immediately after warming is a strong dynamic indicator of embryo quality. Reprod Biomed Online. 2025;51(5):104989. Reproductive BioMedicine Online