The short answer
Usually not, if the aim is a better chance of a baby. ESHRE's 2022 guideline recommends against routine surgery before IVF for stage I/II endometriosis and for endometriomas, because a live-birth benefit is unclear and endometrioma surgery can lower ovarian reserve 1. Surgery still has a place for pain, for hard-to-reach ovaries, and for a fluid-filled tube 1,7.
After a failed cycle, women with endometriosis are often offered one of two things: an operation 'to clean things up' before the next attempt, or several months of injections to switch the disease off first. Both sound like they should help. When the goal is a live birth, ESHRE recommends against doing either routinely 1.
This page sets out what ESHRE's 2022 endometriosis guideline and the Cochrane reviews say about each, and compares having surgery first with going straight back to IVF 1,5. It separates two questions that often get merged in the same consultation: treating pain, and improving IVF odds.
How common is this?
Up to 50%
Estimated share of women with infertility who have endometriosis (ESHRE 2022, citing prevalence studies; the exact figure is unknown)1
Similar
Live birth per woman after IVF/ICSI, with versus without endometriosis, meta-analysis of 13 studies (12,682 patients); lower in stage III/IV disease2
About 2 fewer eggs
Average difference in eggs collected per cycle, women with endometriosis versus without, same meta-analysis (mean difference −1.98)2
1.13 ng/ml
Average fall in AMH after endometrioma cystectomy, meta-analysis of 8 prospective studies (237 patients)4
Reading your report
- rASRM stage I–IV
- The revised American Society for Reproductive Medicine staging, from I (minimal) to IV (severe), based on what was seen at surgery.
- Endometrioma
- A cyst of endometriosis inside the ovary, sometimes called a 'chocolate cyst'.
- Deep endometriosis
- Endometriosis that grows deeper into tissue, for example into the bowel, bladder or the ligaments behind the uterus.
- Cystectomy
- Surgery that removes the lining of an endometrioma from the ovary. ESHRE prefers it to draining and burning the cyst when surgery is done, because recurrence is lower 1.
- Down-regulation / long GnRH agonist pre-treatment
- Three months or more of GnRH agonist injections to suppress the disease before IVF, sometimes called the 'ultralong protocol' 1,5.
- EFI (Endometriosis Fertility Index)
- A score calculated after surgery that estimates the chance of natural pregnancy. ESHRE uses it to decide who should move on to IVF after surgery 1.
- Hydrosalpinx
- A blocked fallopian tube filled with fluid.
Likely causes, most common first
| Cause | How you'd know | Test that tells you |
|---|---|---|
| Fewer eggs than expected | Low egg count or cancelled cycle. Endometriosis and endometriomas are linked to fewer eggs and more cancellations 2,3; previous ovarian surgery can lower AMH 4. | AMH or antral follicle count; review of any past ovarian surgery |
| More severe (stage III/IV) disease | Your operation note or scan report. In the meta-analysis, live birth was lower in stage III/IV than in women without endometriosis 2. | Surgical staging from past operation notes; imaging |
| A fluid-filled blocked tube (hydrosalpinx) | Seen on ultrasound or HSG | Tubal imaging; Cochrane found salpingectomy probably raises clinical pregnancy rates before IVF 7 |
| Nothing specific to endometriosis | Overall live birth rates after IVF were similar with and without endometriosis in the largest meta-analysis 2, so the usual embryo and transfer factors apply. | The same review as any failed cycle: see our implantation failure and tests pages |
What did not cause this
"I should have changed my diet or tried acupuncture"
ESHRE found no clear evidence that nutrition, Chinese medicine, acupuncture, physiotherapy, exercise or psychological interventions increase the chance of pregnancy with endometriosis, and made no recommendation for any of them 1.
"Delaying surgery made IVF fail"
ESHRE recommends against routine surgery before IVF to improve live birth for stage I/II disease or endometriomas 1. In a meta-analysis, women whose endometrioma was operated on before IVF had similar live birth rates to those who were not operated on 3.
"IVF will make my endometriosis worse"
ESHRE says women can be reassured about the safety of ART, because recurrence rates are not higher than in women who do not have ART 1.
"Stress caused this"
A BMJ meta-analysis of 14 studies (3,583 women) found that anxiety or depression before treatment was not associated with whether a cycle led to pregnancy 9.
Should I have endometriosis surgery before my next IVF cycle?
Not routinely, if the reason is to improve IVF success. For stage I/II endometriosis, ESHRE recommends against routine surgery before ART to improve live birth because the potential benefits are unclear (strong recommendation, low-quality evidence) 1. For endometriomas, it recommends against routine surgery before ART because current evidence shows no benefit and surgery is likely to harm ovarian reserve (strong recommendation, low-quality evidence) 1.
The numbers behind that: in a meta-analysis, women who had endometrioma surgery before IVF had similar live birth (odds ratio 0.90; 5 studies, 655 women) and similar egg numbers to women who did not 3. Removing an endometrioma lowered AMH by an average of 1.13 ng/ml across 8 prospective studies 4.
For deep endometriosis, ESHRE says the decision should be guided mainly by pain and your preference, because its effect on IVF outcome is uncertain for lack of randomised trials (strong recommendation, very low-quality evidence) 1.
When does surgery before IVF still make sense?
ESHRE says surgery for an endometrioma before ART can be considered to improve pain or to make follicles reachable at egg collection (good practice point) 1. Surgery is also one of the options it recommends for endometriosis pain in general 1. Those are real reasons. They are different from improving the chance of a baby, and it is fair to ask which one your doctor has in mind.
A fluid-filled blocked tube is the clearest exception. A 2020 Cochrane review found that removing it before IVF probably increases the clinical pregnancy rate (risk ratio 2.02; 4 trials, 455 women; moderate-quality evidence); no trial reported live birth for that comparison 7.
If surgery is done on an endometrioma, ESHRE recommends removing the cyst wall (cystectomy) rather than draining and burning it, and taking specific care to minimise damage to the ovary 1. If ovarian endometriosis is extensive, it recommends discussing the pros and cons of freezing eggs, while noting the true benefit is unknown 1.
Does surgery help if I want to try naturally instead?
That is where the surgical evidence is stronger. For stage I/II disease, ESHRE says operative laparoscopy could be offered because it improves ongoing pregnancy rates (weak recommendation, low-quality evidence) 1. A 2020 Cochrane review found that laparoscopic treatment probably improves viable intrauterine pregnancy compared with diagnostic laparoscopy alone (odds ratio 1.89; 3 trials, 528 women); no trial reported live birth 6.
ESHRE advises that the choice of surgery should weigh pain, age, preferences, previous surgery, other fertility factors, ovarian reserve and the Endometriosis Fertility Index 1. After surgery, it uses that index, along with results such as the partner's semen analysis, to identify women who may need to move on to ART 1. Surgery first and IVF are therefore different plans, not two routes to the same next cycle.
Should I have months of GnRH agonist injections before IVF?
ESHRE recommends against extended GnRH agonist treatment before ART to improve live birth in women with endometriosis, because the benefit is uncertain (strong recommendation, very low-quality evidence) 1. This 'ultralong' approach was recommended in earlier guidance and was dropped in 2022 1.
The Cochrane review behind the change pooled 8 trials with 640 women. For live birth there was only one trial, of 147 women, which found fewer live births with three or more months of agonist pre-treatment (risk ratio 0.48), but on very low-quality evidence; the reviewers concluded they were uncertain whether it affects live birth either way 5.
The same question comes up before frozen transfers. ESHRE's 2023 recommendations on repeated implantation failure note that endometriosis is sometimes suspected as a hidden cause and that GnRH agonist pre-treatment has been tried for that reason; they do not recommend its empirical use 8. ESHRE also found insufficient evidence to recommend months of the contraceptive pill or progestogens before ART 1.
Does the IVF protocol need to change because of endometriosis?
ESHRE says no specific IVF protocol can be recommended for endometriosis. Antagonist and agonist protocols can both be offered, according to your and your doctor's preferences, because no difference in pregnancy or live birth has been shown (weak recommendation, very low-quality evidence) 1.
For women with an endometrioma, ESHRE says antibiotics may be given at egg collection, although the risk of an ovarian abscess after egg collection is low (good practice point) 1. For broader changes to stimulation after a failed cycle, see our page on changing protocol.
It depends on…
What is the operation being suggested for?
To improve my IVF chances, with stage I/II endometriosis
ESHRE recommends against routine surgery for this reason; the benefit is unclear 1.
To improve my IVF chances, with an endometrioma
ESHRE recommends against it routinely: no benefit shown, and likely harm to ovarian reserve 1,4.
For pain
Surgery is a recognised option for pain 1. Decide it as a pain decision, knowing it is unlikely to change IVF odds.
Because the ovaries are hard to reach for egg collection
ESHRE says surgery can be considered for access to the follicles 1.
For a fluid-filled blocked tube
Cochrane found removing it probably improves clinical pregnancy before IVF 7.
Has a long course of GnRH agonist injections been suggested?
Before the next stimulation
ESHRE recommends against it to improve live birth 1; Cochrane is uncertain either way 5.
Before a frozen transfer, after transfers that failed
ESHRE's implantation-failure recommendations do not recommend empirical GnRH agonist pre-treatment 8.
Surgery first or straight to IVF: what the evidence says
| Surgery first, then IVF | Straight to IVF | |
|---|---|---|
| Live birth, stage I/II | No clear benefit; ESHRE recommends against routine surgery (strong) 1 | IVF can be performed; similar live birth to women without endometriosis overall 1,2 |
| Live birth, endometrioma | Similar live birth to no surgery, odds ratio 0.90 3; ESHRE recommends against routine surgery (strong) 1 | Similar live birth to women without an endometrioma, odds ratio 0.98 3 |
| Ovarian reserve | AMH fell by 1.13 ng/ml on average after cystectomy 4 | Endometrioma itself is linked to slightly fewer eggs and more cancelled cycles 3 |
| Pain | Surgery is one recommended option for pain 1 | IVF does not treat pain |
| Deep endometriosis | Decide mainly on pain and preference; effect on IVF uncertain 1 | ART can be performed; it does not seem to increase recurrence 1 |
| Chance of natural pregnancy | Stage I/II: improves ongoing pregnancy (weak recommendation) 1,6 | Not applicable |
| Fluid-filled blocked tube | Removing it probably raises clinical pregnancy, risk ratio 2.02 7 | Clinical pregnancy rates were lower without surgery in the Cochrane trials 7 |
| Ovaries hard to reach at egg collection | Surgery can be considered (good practice point) 1 | Collection may not be possible |
| Time | Adds an operation and recovery before the next cycle | Next cycle can start sooner |
What's worth checking
- Your stage (I–IV) and whether you have an endometrioma or deep disease, from operation notes or scan reports.
- Any past ovarian surgery, and your AMH or antral follicle count before and after it 4.
- Whether a hydrosalpinx has been ruled out on scan or HSG 7.
- If surgery is proposed: is it for pain, for access to the ovaries, or to improve IVF odds 1?
- If months of GnRH agonist injections are proposed: what evidence supports it for you 1,5?
- Which protocol was used last time, and whether a change is being proposed because of endometriosis 1.
- Your partner's semen analysis, which ESHRE says should be considered when deciding next steps 1.
What could change next cycle
8 options, by strength of evidence
- Good evidence it helps 1
- Mixed, or some groups only 1
- Not enough studies yet 4
- Evidence says it doesn't help 2
Ratings follow the evidence reviews cited beside each option, not our opinion.
- Removing a hydrosalpinx before the next transferGood evidence it helps
Cochrane 2020: probably increases clinical pregnancy (moderate-quality evidence); live birth not reported 7.
- Surgery for pain or to reach the folliclesMixed, or some groups only
ESHRE: can be considered for these reasons 1; it is not expected to raise IVF live birth 1,3.
- Routine surgery for stage I/II disease before IVFNot enough studies yet
ESHRE: not recommended routinely, because the potential benefit for live birth is unclear 1.
- Routine endometrioma surgery before IVFEvidence says it doesn't help
ESHRE: no benefit shown and likely harm to ovarian reserve 1; live birth similar with or without surgery 3.
- Three months or more of GnRH agonist before IVFNot enough studies yet
ESHRE: not recommended (strong) 1; Cochrane: uncertain effect on live birth, very low-quality evidence 5.
- Months of the pill or progestogens before IVFNot enough studies yet
ESHRE: insufficient evidence to recommend it 1.
- Switching between antagonist and agonist protocols because of endometriosisEvidence says it doesn't help
ESHRE: no difference in pregnancy or live birth has been shown 1.
- Diet, supplements or acupuncture to improve fertilityNot enough studies yet
ESHRE: no recommendation possible; benefits and harms unclear 1.
Questions to ask your doctor
- Is this operation meant to treat pain, to reach my ovaries, or to improve my IVF chances, and what evidence supports that for my stage 1?
- If you operate on the endometrioma, what might it do to my AMH and my next egg collection 1,4?
- Has a hydrosalpinx been ruled out 7?
- Why are you suggesting months of injections before IVF, given ESHRE recommends against it 1?
- Is my stage of endometriosis likely to have affected this cycle, or does it look like a transfer or embryo issue?
- If I would rather try naturally for a while after surgery, what does my Endometriosis Fertility Index suggest 1?
Questions people ask
Is it safe to do IVF with an endometrioma left in place?
ESHRE's guidance allows ART with an endometrioma in place and recommends against removing it routinely first 1. It suggests antibiotics may be given at egg collection, though the risk of abscess is low 1. Endometriomas can change appearance in pregnancy, and ESHRE recommends referral to an experienced centre if an unusual-looking one is seen 1.
Does endometriosis affect egg quality or implantation?
Should I take hormone treatment after surgery to improve my chances of pregnancy?
Is IUI an option instead of IVF with endometriosis?
For stage I/II endometriosis, ESHRE says IUI with ovarian stimulation may be used because it increases pregnancy rates compared with no treatment or IUI alone (weak recommendation) 1. For stage III/IV with open tubes, its value is uncertain but it could be considered 1. ESHRE describes ART as especially suited when tubes are damaged, there is male factor, the EFI is low or other treatments have failed 1.
How big does an endometrioma have to be before it should be removed?
ESHRE's 2022 guideline gives no size cut-off. Its strong recommendation against routinely operating on an endometrioma before ART to improve live birth is not qualified by how big the cyst is 1. The two reasons it does accept for operating — endometriosis pain, and making the follicles reachable at egg collection — do not rest on a number either 1. If a size is being quoted to you, it is fair to ask which published recommendation it comes from.
Can endometriosis be diagnosed without a laparoscopy?
Yes, and that is one of the bigger changes in ESHRE's 2022 guideline. Laparoscopy is no longer treated as the diagnostic gold standard: it is now recommended in patients with negative imaging results, or where empirical treatment was unsuccessful or inappropriate 1. Imaging comes first. ESHRE adds that laparoscopic findings should be confirmed by histology, while negative histology does not entirely rule the disease out 1.
Does adenomyosis make IVF less likely to work?
The evidence points that way, though not from randomised trials. A meta-analysis of 11 comparative studies (519 women with adenomyosis, 1,535 without) found lower implantation, clinical pregnancy, ongoing pregnancy and live birth rates after IVF, and a higher miscarriage rate 10. A separate review of 104 papers put the odds of miscarriage with adenomyosis at 3.40 times higher (95% CI 1.41–8.65) 11. ESHRE's implantation-failure group notes that the effect of treating adenomyosis on pregnancy or live birth after repeated failure has not been evaluated 8.
My endometrioma has come back. Should I have it removed again before IVF?
ESHRE's recommendation against routine endometrioma surgery before ART is not qualified by whether you have had surgery before 1. A prospective controlled study of 28 women (17 first operations, 11 for recurrence) found that repeat surgery removed thicker cyst walls containing more ovarian tissue, and that the operated ovary had a lower antral follicle count than the other side only in the recurrence group; the authors concluded that indications for repeat surgery should be reconsidered with caution 12.
Should I freeze my eggs before endometrioma surgery?
It is a conversation ESHRE asks clinicians to have. Where ovarian endometriosis is extensive, it says the pros and cons of fertility preservation should be discussed, while stating plainly that its true benefit in endometriosis remains unknown (strong recommendation, very low-quality evidence) 1. The reason it usually comes up before rather than after an operation is that removing an endometrioma lowered AMH by an average of 1.13 ng/ml across eight prospective studies 4.
Is pregnancy riskier with endometriosis?
ESHRE says clinicians should be aware there may be an increased risk of first-trimester miscarriage and ectopic pregnancy in women with endometriosis (strong recommendation, low-quality evidence) 1. Other endometriosis-related complications in pregnancy are rare, and ESHRE says the low to moderate quality of the studies means the findings do not warrant increased antenatal monitoring or dissuade women from becoming pregnant 1. A review of 104 papers also reported higher odds of preterm delivery (OR 1.38) and caesarean birth (OR 1.98) 11.
Will pregnancy cure my endometriosis?
No. ESHRE says patients should not be advised to become pregnant with the sole purpose of treating endometriosis, because pregnancy does not always lead to an improvement in symptoms or a reduction in disease progression — a strong recommendation, on very low-quality evidence 1. Treating pain and trying for a baby are separate decisions, and the guideline keeps them separate throughout.
Is a laparoscopy worth doing after failed IVF to look for endometriosis?
Only if something has changed. ESHRE's implantation-failure group says assessment for adenomyosis, endometriosis and submucosal fibroids should be carried out before ART, and that further investigation including MRI or diagnostic laparoscopy should be considered if there is renewed suspicion from emerging clinical signs or ultrasound features noted after repeated failure 8. A cycle failing, on its own, is not described in either ESHRE document as a reason to go looking again.
Sources
- Becker CM, Bokor A, Heikinheimo O, Horne A, Jansen F, Kiesel L, et al.; ESHRE Endometriosis Guideline Group. ESHRE guideline: endometriosis. Hum Reprod Open. 2022;2022(2):hoac009. ESHRE / Human Reproduction Open
- Hamdan M, Omar SZ, Dunselman G, Cheong Y. Influence of endometriosis on assisted reproductive technology outcomes: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Obstet Gynecol. 2015;125(1):79-88. Obstetrics & Gynecology
- Hamdan M, Dunselman G, Li TC, Cheong Y. The impact of endometrioma on IVF/ICSI outcomes: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Hum Reprod Update. 2015;21(6):809-825. Human Reproduction Update
- Raffi F, Metwally M, Amer S. The impact of excision of ovarian endometrioma on ovarian reserve: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2012;97(9):3146-3154. Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism
- Georgiou EX, Melo P, Baker PE, Sallam HN, Arici A, Garcia-Velasco JA, et al. Long-term GnRH agonist therapy before in vitro fertilisation (IVF) for improving fertility outcomes in women with endometriosis. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2019;11:CD013240. Cochrane
- Bafort C, Beebeejaun Y, Tomassetti C, Bosteels J, Duffy JM. Laparoscopic surgery for endometriosis. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020;10:CD011031. Cochrane
- Melo P, Georgiou EX, Johnson N, van Voorst SF, Strandell A, Mol BWJ, et al. Surgical treatment for tubal disease in women due to undergo in vitro fertilisation. Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2020;10:CD002125. Cochrane
- ESHRE Working Group on Recurrent Implantation Failure; Cimadomo D, de los Santos MJ, Griesinger G, et al. ESHRE good practice recommendations on recurrent implantation failure. Hum Reprod Open. 2023;2023(3):hoad023. ESHRE / Human Reproduction Open
- Boivin J, Griffiths E, Venetis CA. Emotional distress in infertile women and failure of assisted reproductive technologies: meta-analysis of prospective psychosocial studies. BMJ. 2011;342:d223. BMJ
- Younes G, Tulandi T. Effects of adenomyosis on in vitro fertilization treatment outcomes: a meta-analysis. Fertil Steril. 2017;108(3):483-490.e3. Fertility and Sterility (ASRM)
- Horton J, Sterrenburg M, Lane S, Maheshwari A, Li TC, Cheong Y. Reproductive, obstetric, and perinatal outcomes of women with adenomyosis and endometriosis: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Hum Reprod Update. 2019;25(5):592-632. Human Reproduction Update (ESHRE)
- Muzii L, Achilli C, Lecce F, Bianchi A, Franceschetti S, Marchetti C, et al. Second surgery for recurrent endometriomas is more harmful to healthy ovarian tissue and ovarian reserve than first surgery. Fertil Steril. 2015;103(3):738-743. Fertility and Sterility (ASRM)