IVF PulseFree Second Opinion

Changing fertility clinic or doctor

Should you change your IVF clinic or doctor after a failed cycle?

The short answer

Not automatically. Around three quarters of IVF treatments are unsuccessful, so one failed cycle says little about a clinic on its own 11. A change makes more sense when you cannot get a clear explanation, your records or a reasoned plan. If you move, India's 2002 medical ethics regulations require records within 72 hours of a request 1, and frozen embryos need National Board permission 3.

After a failed cycle it is natural to wonder whether another clinic or doctor would have got a different result. Sometimes the honest answer is no: the cycle failed for reasons any clinic would have faced. Sometimes the way the cycle was run, explained or followed up gives you real reasons to move.

This page helps you tell the two apart. It covers what a failed cycle can and cannot tell you about a clinic, how to get your records, how to check a clinic's registration under India's ART (Regulation) Act 2021, what moving frozen embryos involves, and how staying and switching compare. It does not recommend any clinic.

Reading your report

Discharge certificate
A certificate the ART Act requires the clinic to give you, stating details of the procedure performed (section 21(h)) 3.
ART registration number
The number a state appropriate authority gives a clinic when it registers it under the ART Act. Registration lasts five years, and the certificate must be displayed with its validity dates 3.
Level 1 and Level 2 clinics
Under the ART Rules, 2022, a Level 1 clinic only does intrauterine insemination (IUI). Egg collection, IVF and ICSI, embryo transfer and embryo storage need a Level 2 clinic 4.
National ART & Surrogacy Registry
The central database the Act set up for all ART clinics and banks in India 3, run online by the Department of Health Research 7.
Appropriate authority
The state or union territory body that grants, suspends and cancels clinic registration and investigates complaints of breaches of the Act 3.
Grievance cell
A complaints mechanism every ART clinic and bank must maintain (section 21(f)) 3. The ART Rules set out the complaint format as Form 5 4.

Does a failed IVF cycle mean the clinic did something wrong?

Usually it does not show that on its own. The HFEA, the UK regulator, tells patients that around three quarters of IVF treatment is unsuccessful 11. In a UK study of 156,947 women, 29.5% had a baby from their first cycle 12. ESHRE's 2023 recommendations suggest looking for a cause of failed transfers only once the cumulative predicted chance of implantation has passed 60% 13.

Comparing clinics by headline success rates has limits too. The HFEA says most clinics are broadly as good as each other, and that small differences in success rates are usually down to the different types of patients they treat 8. It adds that differences of one or two percentage points are often down to chance 9.

What a failed cycle can reveal is how a clinic handles failure: whether it explains what happened, shares your records, and gives reasons for what it proposes next. Those are things you can judge now.

What are good reasons to change clinic or doctor after a failed cycle?

Reasons that point to the care, rather than the outcome, carry more weight.

  • You cannot get a clear explanation. The ART Act requires clinics to counsel you on the implications and chances of success of procedures in that clinic, and to tell you their advantages, disadvantages, cost, side effects and risks 3.
  • Your records are refused or delayed. The 2002 regulations set a 72-hour deadline, and list refusing to provide records within it as misconduct (regulation 7.2) 1.
  • The same plan is offered again with no reason, even though enough embryos have been transferred to pass ESHRE's 60% threshold 13.
  • You are pressed to pay for add-ons without a clear reason. The HFEA advises asking why an add-on is being offered and whether it may benefit you specifically 14.
  • The clinic cannot show a current registration certificate, or does not appear on the national registry 3,6.
  • Practical reasons count. The HFEA lists cost, location, how other patients rate a clinic and the counselling it provides among the factors worth weighing 9.
  • Weaker on its own: another clinic quoting a higher success rate. The HFEA says individual clinic rates cannot tell you how likely you are to have a baby 8.

How do you get your IVF records before deciding?

Regulation 1.3.2 of the Indian Medical Council (Professional Conduct, Etiquette and Ethics) Regulations, 2002 says that if a patient or authorised attendant requests medical records, the request 'may be duly acknowledged and documents shall be issued within the period of 72 hours' 1. Regulation 1.3.1 requires doctors to keep indoor-patient records for 3 years from the start of treatment 1. The National Medical Commission issued replacement conduct regulations in August 2023, but its website lists a later notification keeping them in abeyance 2.

Separately, the ART Act requires the clinic to give you a discharge certificate with details of the procedure performed 3. Make the request in writing, keep a dated copy, and ask for copies of the stimulation chart, embryology report and transfer notes rather than a summary. The second-opinion page lists what each document should contain.

Getting your records does not commit you to leaving. Nothing in regulation 1.3.2 ties a request to ending treatment 1, and having them makes a second opinion possible whichever way you decide.

How do you check whether an IVF clinic is registered under the ART Act?

Under section 15 of the ART (Regulation) Act 2021, no one may run a clinic offering ART unless it is registered under the Act 3. Registration is valid for five years, and the clinic must display its certificate in a conspicuous place, showing how long it is valid 3. The prescribed certificate states whether the clinic is Level 1 or Level 2 4; IVF needs Level 2 4.

The Department of Health Research runs the National ART & Surrogacy Registry as an online public record of clinics and banks 7. When we checked on 22 September 2026, its dashboard showed 8,095 ART clinic applications received, 4,684 registered and 1,579 rejected 6.

  • Open registry.artsurrogacy.gov.in and choose the list of registered ART clinics 6.
  • Find the clinic by name or city. Each entry shows the name, address, state, email, registration number and a link to the certificate 6. The list is long, so your browser's find-in-page helps.
  • Check that the address matches the branch you would attend. The Act defines a clinic by its premises, and the State Board must inspect the premises before registration 3.
  • Open the certificate and check the level and the validity dates 4.
  • A separate list shows rejected applications 6.
  • If a clinic is not listed, ask it for its certificate and registration number. The portal lists each state's appropriate authority, which maintains registration records 3,7.

What does registration tell you, and what does it not?

Registration means the appropriate authority was satisfied that the clinic had the prescribed staff, infrastructure, equipment and diagnostic facilities, and that the State Board inspected the premises 3. It is a minimum legal standard, not a measure of results.

The Act says the registry is to collect each clinic's services and outcomes 3, but we found no clinic-level success rates published on the portal or the registry when we checked 6,7. Any success rate you are quoted comes from the clinic itself, so ask what it measures: per egg collection or per transfer, and for which age group.

Can you move frozen embryos to another clinic in India?

Yes, but it needs permission, not just paperwork. Section 29 of the ART Act prohibits transferring embryos to anyone, except transferring your own gametes and embryos for personal use with the permission of the National Board 3. The HFEA notes, for UK patients, that moving is much easier between cycles than during one 10; that makes the gap after a failed cycle a practical time to start.

Rule 19 of the ART Rules, added in February 2023, says anyone moving their own embryos within or outside India must apply using Forms 16 to 24 and get the National Board's permission first 5. For a move within India, that means:

  • Form 16: the application, naming both clinics, the number of embryos and the purpose, with a copy of your Aadhaar 5.
  • Form 19: an affidavit from the couple, on non-judicial stamp paper, sworn before a magistrate or notary public 5.
  • Form 21: an affidavit from the clinic holding the embryos, stating how many were created, used and remain 5.
  • Form 23: an affidavit from the receiving clinic that it is willing to accept them 5.
  • Embryos can be stored for no more than ten years under section 28(2), so note when yours were frozen 3.
  • We found no published processing time or fee for this permission. Ask both clinics before you book treatment at the new one.

Is it awkward to leave, or to ask for a different doctor?

It should not be treated that way. The 2002 regulations say that in every consultation the benefit to the patient is of foremost importance, and that doctors should be frank with the patient 1. They also say a doctor who has taken on a case should not withdraw without adequate notice to the patient 1.

Changing doctor within the same clinic is also an option, and keeps your records and any frozen embryos where they are. Under the ART Act, your treatment information is confidential and may be disclosed only to the national registry, in an emergency at your request, or by court order 3.

It depends on…

Why are you thinking of changing?

The cycle failed, but it was explained and the plan makes sense

One failure is weak evidence about a clinic 11. Staying keeps the team that saw how you responded.

I could not get an explanation, or my records

Request records in writing; the 2002 regulations set a 72-hour deadline 1. A refusal is itself a reason to move.

The same plan is offered again with no reason

Ask why. ESHRE suggests counselling on investigation once past its 60% threshold 13; a second opinion on your records can help before deciding.

Cost, distance or trust

These are legitimate reasons; the HFEA lists cost, location and counselling among the factors to weigh 9.

Do you have frozen embryos at your current clinic?

Yes

Moving them needs National Board permission and affidavits from both clinics 3,5. Start this before booking treatment elsewhere.

No

The move is mainly your records and a new consultation.

Is the clinic you are considering registered for IVF?

Listed on the registry, with a valid Level 2 certificate

Registration is confirmed 4,6. Judge the rest on explanation, plan and practicalities.

Not listed, or it cannot show a certificate

The Act does not allow an unregistered clinic to offer ART 3. Ask for its registration number and check with the state appropriate authority 7.

Stay or switch: what each can fix

What is bothering youStaying can fix it if…Switching makes sense if…
One cycle did not workIt was explained; about three quarters of IVF treatment is unsuccessful 11A failure alone is weak evidence of poor care 11
No one explained whyYou get a proper review appointment; counselling is a duty under the ART Act 3The clinic will not discuss it or share records 1
The same plan againThere is a stated reason, such as being below ESHRE's 60% threshold 13No reason is given after several failed transfers 13
Doubts about the labThe clinic shares its own fertilisation and blastocyst rates for patients like youIt cannot or will not tell you
Frozen embryosThey stay where they areYou are prepared for the National Board permission process 3,5
Success rates elsewhere look higherSmall differences are usually patient mix or chance 8,9The other clinic explains what its rates measure and for whom

What's worth checking

  • Ask your current clinic for a stage-by-stage explanation of the cycle and what it would change.
  • Request full records and the discharge certificate in writing; keep a dated copy 1,3.
  • Note how many embryos are frozen, where, and since when 3.
  • Look up any clinic you are considering on the national registry 6.
  • Check that its certificate says Level 2 and is still valid 4.
  • Ask any new clinic how it would handle the embryo transfer permission forms 5.
  • Ask each clinic what its quoted success rate measures: per egg collection or per transfer, and for which ages.
  • Before paying for add-ons at either clinic, ask why each is offered and whether it helps you specifically 14.

Questions to ask your doctor

  1. Can you explain, stage by stage, why you think this cycle did not work?
  2. What would you change next time, and why?
  3. What are this clinic's live birth rates for women my age, per egg collection and per transfer?
  4. Can I have complete copies of my records and the discharge certificate?
  5. For a new clinic: what is your ART registration number and level, and when does the certificate expire?
  6. For a new clinic: will you accept my frozen embryos and sign the receiving-clinic affidavit?

Questions people ask

Can my clinic refuse to release my frozen embryos if I move?

Moving your own embryos needs the National Board's permission, and the application includes an affidavit from the clinic holding them 3,5. We did not find a provision allowing a clinic to refuse. If it will not cooperate, its grievance cell and the state appropriate authority, which investigates complaints under the Act, are the routes 3.

Do I have to tell my clinic why I want my records?

Regulation 1.3.2 covers any request by the patient or an authorised attendant and does not mention giving a reason 1. A short written request with the date is enough to start the 72-hour period.

Does ART Act registration mean a clinic is good?

It means the clinic met the prescribed standards for staff, infrastructure and equipment and its premises were inspected 3. It does not measure results, and we found no clinic-level outcome data on the national registry 6.

Is it better to change the doctor or the whole clinic?

It depends on what went wrong. If the concern is communication or the treatment plan, a different doctor at the same clinic keeps your records and embryos in place. If the concern is the lab, the records or the registration, a different clinic is the only real change.

Do I need a no-objection certificate from my clinic to move to another IVF clinic?

We found no such requirement. What the rules do give you is your records within 72 hours of a written request 1, and, if frozen embryos are moving, the National Board's permission with affidavits from you, the clinic holding them and the clinic receiving them 3,5. A new clinic asking for your old reports is a practical request, not a clearance from the old one.

Can the clinic hold back my reports until I clear the bill?

Regulation 1.3.2 sets a flat 72-hour deadline for issuing requested medical records and does not make it conditional on payment 1. Refusing to provide them within 72 hours when the patient or an authorised representative asks is listed among acts of professional misconduct in regulation 7.2 1. Any dispute about fees is a separate matter from your right to the records.

How do I complain about an IVF clinic in India?

Start with the clinic's grievance cell, which every ART clinic and bank must maintain under section 21(f) 3; the ART Rules, 2022 set the complaint format as Form 5 4. Beyond the clinic, the state appropriate authority investigates breaches of the Act and can suspend or cancel registration 3, and the national portal lists each state's authority 7.

What happens to our frozen embryos after ten years?

Section 28(2) of the ART Act says a donor gamete or an embryo may be stored for no more than ten years, after which it is allowed to perish or, with the consent of the commissioning couple or individual, donated to a research organisation registered under the Act 3. Note the date yours were frozen, and ask what the storage consent form you signed commits you to.

Can we move our frozen embryos out of India?

Only with permission. Section 29 prohibits transferring embryos to any party within or outside India, except your own for personal use with the National Board's permission 3. Rule 19 of the ART Rules requires an application in Forms 16 to 24 before any such move 5. We found no published processing time or fee, so raise it with both clinics before committing to treatment abroad.

Is a big IVF chain better than a small clinic?

Size is not what regulators tell patients to compare. The HFEA says most clinics are broadly as good as each other and that small differences in success rates usually reflect the types of patients treated 8, and it lists cost, location, counselling and patient and inspector ratings among the things to weigh 9. In India, check the certificate says Level 2 and is still valid 4.

What if the clinic says my records are lost, or the clinic has closed?

A clinic that closes before its ten-year record-keeping period ends must immediately transfer its records to the National Registry's central database, so the registry and the state appropriate authority, which maintains registration details and investigates breaches of the Act, are the places to ask 3. For a clinic still open, put the request in writing: refusing records within 72 hours is listed as misconduct 1.

Can I consult a new clinic while my embryos are still at the old one?

Yes. A consultation moves nothing. The HFEA notes that changing clinics is much easier between treatment cycles than in the middle of one 10, and the embryo transfer application needs affidavits from both the holding and the receiving clinic, so the new clinic has to be chosen before anything moves 5. Ask the new clinic what it needs from you first.

Sources

  1. Medical Council of India. Indian Medical Council (Professional Conduct, Etiquette and Ethics) Regulations, 2002 (as amended), regulations 1.3.1, 1.3.2, 2.4, 3.2 and 7.2. Medical Council of India, hosted by the National Medical Commission
  2. National Medical Commission. Rules and Regulations: Registered Medical Practitioner (Professional Conduct) Regulations, 2023 (2 August 2023) and amendment notification of 23 August 2023 keeping them in abeyance. National Medical Commission
  3. The Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Act, 2021 (No. 42 of 2021), sections 9, 11, 13, 15, 16, 21, 23, 28 and 29. Gazette of India Extraordinary, December 2021. Government of India (Gazette of India)
  4. Ministry of Health and Family Welfare (Department of Health Research). Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Rules, 2022 (G.S.R. 419(E), 7 June 2022), rules 3 and 11, Forms 3 and 5. Government of India, National ART & Surrogacy Portal
  5. Ministry of Health and Family Welfare (Department of Health Research). Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Amendment Rules, 2023 (G.S.R. 126(E), 24 February 2023): rule 19 and Forms 16–24. Government of India, National ART & Surrogacy Portal
  6. Department of Health Research. National ART & Surrogacy Registry: dashboard and lists of registered and rejected ART clinics. Department of Health Research and NIC, Government of India
  7. Department of Health Research. National ART & Surrogacy Portal: National ART & Surrogacy Registry page, and lists of State ART & Surrogacy Appropriate Authorities. Department of Health Research, Ministry of Health & Family Welfare
  8. Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority. Choose a fertility clinic. HFEA (UK regulator)
  9. Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority. Finding the best fertility clinic for you. HFEA (UK regulator)
  10. Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority. Problems at your fertility clinic. HFEA (UK regulator)
  11. Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority. Coping if treatment doesn't work. HFEA (UK regulator)
  12. Smith ADAC, Tilling K, Nelson SM, Lawlor DA. Live-birth rate associated with repeat in vitro fertilization treatment cycles. JAMA. 2015;314(24):2654-2662. JAMA
  13. ESHRE Working Group on Recurrent Implantation Failure; Cimadomo D, de los Santos MJ, Griesinger G, Lainas G, Le Clef N, et al. ESHRE good practice recommendations on recurrent implantation failure. Hum Reprod Open. 2023;2023(3):hoad023. ESHRE / Human Reproduction Open
  14. Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority. Treatment add-ons with limited evidence. HFEA (UK regulator)

Tools for this step

WhatsApp us